Who Pays More for Insurance Premiums?

It surprises anyone new to this business that two cars of the same brand, the same model, even the same year can have insurance premiums that differ significantly from each other. Yet the insurance company prices the risk, not the car; risk is a combination not so much of the vehicle itself, but of who uses it, where, for what purpose, and how. A driver who knows the variables behind the premium calculation can easily read why the figure reflected on their policy is high or low - and can push that figure down with the options available to them. This article contains not current prices, but a calculation method that will remain valid years from now.
Casco and Traffic Insurance Mean Different Risks, Different Prices
First, it is necessary to distinguish what each of the two products pays for, because the factors that determine the premium are shaped accordingly. Mandatory traffic insurance covers the damages of the other party and third parties in an accident where the insured is at fault; it does not pay for damage to your own vehicle. Casco, on the other hand, secures the damages to your vehicle and your driver. In traffic insurance, the coverage limits and tariff framework are set by the state; with casco, you can customize the scope, and the coverages you choose become a direct part of the premium.
It is worth noting one detail: traffic insurance does not pay for a stolen vehicle. Theft coverage falls within the scope of casco; according to the general terms of casco, a stolen vehicle is compensated based on its market value on the day of the theft. That is why theft statistics are a variable that carries particular weight in the casco premium especially.
What Are the Main Risk Factors That Determine the Premium?

Highlights
- The premium is set on the risk, not the car: driver profile, residence, purpose of use, and claims history are the most heavily weighted variables.
- The effect of age is not linear: those under 30 and newly licensed drivers are high-risk; the 35-55 age range is the most advantageous group.
- An old car is not always cheap: in vehicles over 10 years old, parts availability pushes the premium back up.
- In traffic insurance, claims history is reflected in the price through a 7-step system; the starting point is step 4.
- The no-claims discount lowers the premium noticeably from the first years onward; casco with a deductible provides an additional discount.
Driver age and length of license holding
In the insurer's eyes, experience is the premium. In casco, drivers under 30 and those with a short license history are considered high-risk; drivers over 30 with roughly five years of licensure encounter noticeably more favorable premiums. The most advantageous bracket is usually the 35-55 age range. In traffic insurance, the effect of age is more limited than in casco; however, young drivers without an insurance history may encounter a high-risk premium there as well. The age of your license is not a less influential criterion than the age of your car.
The value, age, and parts cost of the vehicle
The backbone of the casco premium is the casco value of the vehicle. The Türkiye Insurance Association publishes a Casco Value List updated every month; as the vehicle's value rises, the potential total-loss compensation, and therefore the premium, increases. Here, the expectation that a vehicle gets cheaper as it ages often turns out to be wrong as well: new vehicles are expensive due to their high value, while mid-aged vehicles with abundant parts and stable value are usually in the most favorable premium period; for vehicles aged 10 years and over, premiums may rise again as parts availability becomes harder and repair costs increase.
The brand and model effect also comes into play here. Of two vehicles in the same price band, the model with imported spare parts and difficult, costly labor may have a noticeably higher premium. Especially in imported vehicles, the increase in spare parts and labor costs is one of the main reasons for premium increases. For luxury segment vehicles, both repair and theft statistics push the premium upward.
Place of residence and license plate code
The province where the vehicle is registered is reflected in the price based on traffic density, accident frequency, and theft statistics. In large metropolitan areas, especially provinces with heavy traffic and high theft risk, premiums are above average. This mechanism, called the province coefficient in traffic insurance, together with vehicle type, engine displacement, and driver age, carries the greatest weight in the premium. A small historical note here: although the requirement to declare one's place of residence was abolished over time, the province where the vehicle is registered continues to effectively influence the premium calculation. In other words, an obsolete condition and an effective coefficient are not the same thing.
Purpose of use
Vehicles used commercially generally command higher premiums compared to privately used vehicles, as they stay on duty longer during the day and in heavier traffic. In traffic insurance, too, engine displacement, year of manufacture, and purpose of use are fundamental inputs to the calculation. A commercial vehicle working ten hours a day and a private car used only on weekends do not fall in the same risk table, even if they are the same model.
How Do Claims History and the Step System Work?
In traffic insurance, claims history is converted into price through a seven-step system. A new driver starts from step 4; the step changes according to the claims situation at the end of the policy period. Dropping one step after an at-fault accident means paying a higher premium the following year. On the comprehensive insurance side, the mechanism is more flexible: claim-free periods return as discounts, while a driver who files claims frequently is subject to a surcharge, that is, an additional loading on the price. Under current practice, the traffic insurance premium is determined according to the claims history of the vehicle operator.
One balancing element should also be known: the authority to set maximum premium amounts belongs to the regulator, and a maximum premium is set for drivers who cannot obtain a standard quote. In other words, the system penalizes the high-risk profile, but does not leave it penniless.
No-Claim Discount and the Concept of Exemption
The no-claim discount is a price advantage granted to drivers with no accident records during the policy period, and it applies to both traffic insurance and comprehensive insurance. The discount begins noticeably after the first claim-free year and grows progressively as claim-free years continue; drivers in higher tiers are spared a significant portion of the premium. Figures for the first-year discount rate may vary from company to company; the point is not the rate, but the mechanism itself: each claim-free year makes the next policy cheaper. A faulty claim can disrupt this accumulation; therefore, covering minor damages out of pocket rather than through the policy is usually profitable in the long run. The no-claim discount protection coverage can also be purchased as an additional coverage on the policy.
Comprehensive insurance with a deductible is one of the clearest ways to reduce the premium. At the time of a claim, the insured bears a small portion of the loss, typically a slice of around one to two percent of the claim amount; in return, a significant discount is gained on the premium. For a low-claim, careful driver profile, it is a sensible trade: take on the small risk, get the big discount.
Why Do Different Prices Appear for the Same Profile?
Insurance companies weight risk criteria according to their own systems. Two quotes starting from the same vehicle, same driver, and same address can differ from one another because companies have different claims experience and portfolio strategies. For this reason, not settling for a single quote and making comparisons is as much a part of the method as the premium itself. The fact that the premium your friend pays for the same model of vehicle differs from yours is not a mystery; it is probably the result of three things: driver profile, place of residence, and claims history. A fourth is policy choices; different coverage packages mean different prices.
Who Pays a More Expensive Premium, and What Are the Ways to Lower the Premium?
To sum up: the premium is highest for young and newly licensed drivers, vehicle owners registered in metropolitan areas, commercial users, operators who frequently file claims, and models with expensive parts or high theft statistics. The most favorable profile is read in reverse: an established driver age, a clean claims history, a quiet region, and a model with plentiful parts. The premium is a reflection of the risk profile, not the vehicle's sticker price; even if you cannot change the profile, you can change the policy.
The cards in your hand are not few: security equipment such as an immobilizer, alarm, and tracking device pulls down the theft risk and therefore the premium; committing to a single driver, taking advantage of applicable occupational discounts, protecting your no-claims history by not passing minor damages through the policy, and evaluating the deductible comprehensive insurance option are concrete steps. Age and region turn in your favor over time; claims history is entirely in your hands. Once the premium calculation is understood, it becomes easier to distinguish the variables that are and are not on your side; the good news is that those on your side take up plenty of room on the list.
Sources
- What Are the Factors That Determine Comprehensive Insurance Prices and the Coverages?
- What Are the Factors Affecting the Comprehensive Insurance Premium? How Is It Calculated?
- Factors Affecting Comprehensive Insurance Prices
- What Is the No-Claims Discount?
- Traffic Insurance Tiers
- No-Claims Discount in Comprehensive Insurance
- Guide to Province Coefficients in Traffic Insurance
- Is There an Age Limit for Comprehensive Insurance?
- Does Traffic Insurance Cover a Stolen Vehicle?
- Notable circular regarding traffic insurance